Does medicating your child make you a lazy parent?

I was listening to the radio the other day, and the local DJ was talking about medicating children. 

In fairness, I didn’t hear the entire show but his point was something along the lines of parents that medicate their children are just lazy parents.

I listened to several callers go back and forth with him on the topic of ADHD. 

He claimed that ADHD kids are just creative and that parents who give their child ADHD medications are simply stifling their creativity. He took the stance that parents should just work harder.



He also made a statement along the lines that you can’t trust doctors or hospitals because they just want to throw medications at your kids. 

Now I will say that there are parents out there in the world today that medicate their child for the wrong reasons.  It’s also fair to say that some doctor are to quick to jump to medications.

I don’t deny either of those as I believe any reasonable person would agree. 

Having said that, I think it’s beyond irresponsible for someone in a position that outs them in the public eye, to preach their opinions as though they are scientific facts.

I believe that doing so is very dangerous. 
I will speak only from my personal experience on this topic and share our story about medicating our children. Please keep in mind that everyone is different and every situation may call for a different response.

I think that the best example I can relate to you is about Elliott’s recent journey with ADHD medications. 

Gavin isn’t the best example because I think fewer people can relate as Gavin’s experience is rather extreme and extremely rare.

For my wife and I, making the decision to put one of our children on medication is one of the most difficult we have ever faced. There are so many things to consider,  like risk vs gain,  side effects and general safety concerns.

When we began to think about putting Elliott on medication it was very, very difficult.  I personally hate the idea of him taking medications. However, I had to put that to the side for the moment and think about Elliott.  Sure Elliott is hyper and can have a hard time focusing, however the biggest concern for me was his anxiety. 

Elliott experiences debilitating anxiety and has for some time. 

I don’t mean he worries on occasion.  I mean he worries constantly about everything and everyone to the point where it’s all consuming.

We worked with his psychologist, psychiatrist and pediatrician – all of whom we completely trust- to help guide us in the best ways to help Elliott. We wanted to explore all of our options. 

Our team of doctors are very conservative when it comes to medications and that’s one of the reasons we like them so much. Medications have always been more of a last resort but at the same time, always on the table.

We decided that because the anxiety was so profoundly impacting Elliott’s quality of life, that medication may be the best option, at least for the immediate future. Sure Elliott was tough to manage in anxious and hyperactive state but that was not our reason for choosing the medication route. 

We had already been working with a therapist for a long time and it simply wasn’t enough. However, the biggest factor we considered was how these things were effecting Elliott’s life. He couldn’t sleep, he was an emotional train wreck, all the time.  He was miserable all around.  It was heartbreaking. 

Read This  How in the world do you adjust your child's ridiculously early bathroom schedule?

Because Elliott was genetically predisposed to ADHD (Lizze has ADHD), we had to take a slightly different approach to providing him with relief via medication. 

After consulting all of his doctors everyone agreed that we should tackle the question of ADHD first.  The reason for that was because it’s the quickest and easiest to treat.  The other thing is that the symptoms were so intertwined that we had to try and tease things out a little bit. 

The result was an immediate change in his quality of life. He was no longer bouncing off the walls and was less impulsive. 

The fact that he reacted to the medication indicates that ADHD is present and responding well.  The other thing we learned is that the ADHD and anxiety exist independently of each other. This basically meant that we have two separate issues to tackle. 

image

Elliott is currently doing well on the ADHD medication and we meet once again with his psychiatrist on Monday to discuss addressing the anxiety.

Our goal would be to address both the ADHD and Anxiety with a single medication and it’s very likely to happen that way.

Overall, Elliott’s life has improved and that’s what’s the most important thing to us.

I realize that some people won’t agree with how we handled this situation, but honestly, I don’t really care.  The thing is, every situation is different. Every child is different.  Simply because one family is able to address things without the use of medications doesn’t mean that the next family can do the same thing. 

Also,  simply because a parent either chooses not to use medication or their child doesn’t need it does not necessarily make them a better parent than the one that chooses medication and does so for the right reasons. 

That’s something that I really believe to be true.  However, your mileage will very because everyone is entitled to his or her own opinion. 

Having said that, we need to be very, very careful not to confuse your opinion as fact.  While your opinion may align with a preponderance of scientific fact not all opinions will do that.  So please be careful.

Going back to what I began with, the DJ I heard on the radio. I believe that he is entitled to his opinion.  However, it think that for anyone to make a blanket statement to the affect of, parents that medicate their children are lazy or somehow bad parents is ignorant and irresponsible at best. 

Choosing to medicate a child is never an easy decision, at least in most cases.  However, for what it’s worth, in my personal opinion, choosing to medicate your child, doesn’t automatically make you a bad or lazy parent.

When done safely, for the right reasons and under the guidance of a trusted medical professional, medication can make a significant improvement in a child’s life.

Anyone that says otherwise is simply sharing their personal opinion and are speaking contrary to the overwhelming preponderance of years and years of scientific data.  Please don’t confuse their opinion with scientific fact.

I would love to hear your personal opinion on this topic as well. Please share your thoughts, views,  experience a day opinions in the comments below.



  • kat13 says:

    We went without medication for 9 years and I got to say it is like day and night now that my daughter is on it. Since she had started her ADHD medication, her anxiety and frustration levels went all the way down and she had accomplished so much since then! It also helps her with a lots of behavior issues that were as a result of high anxiety levels and frustration.
     
    She is old enough now to tell the difference herself. In fact, she told me once on one of the weekends when I forgot to give her the medicine that her brain just doesn't work without it, which was just reassuring that we made the right decision with taking that path as soon as we got the diagnosis. 
     
    What is regarding creativity, it actually increased since then! She is building insanely complex and huge Legos as well as started creating her own small videos, drawing more, and the list just goes on… Where before it, she was  frustrated with any task, we would sit for hours doing simple homework not because she didn't know how to do it, but because she needed help to keep her staying on the task. 
     
    People who say they are against medication for  ADHD and ADD just simply need to educate themselves more about this medical condition. It is as simple as lack of right chemical balance in the brain that medication helps to bring it to the levels than a normal person without ADHD/ADD has. And I would add that preventing medicating those kids, is same as preventing them from creativity!

  • rebeccamagliozzi says:

    I would love to keep my autistic kiddo medication free. However, because he is aggressive at 8 yrs old, and suddenly flares into a rage from 0-100 with no warning, and is now throwing objects like chairs, destroying property, screaming, hurting people, etc, and plagued by constant, debilitating anxiety that nothing else has fixed, I really have  no choice. A lazy parent would let it get to the point where he or someone else got seriously injured and maybe he is hospitalized or placed in juvenile hall. We tried all the natural stuff, special GFCFSF diet, removing allergens, lowering sugar, etc. None of that really worked. So we placed him on Propanolol, the safest medication we could find for rages and aggressive behavior and anxiety. He is now having excellent days at school and is smiling when I pick him up, versus crying, frustrated and saying he believes he is turning into a mean, bad person. As a responsible parent, I have to medicate him because he is dangerous with his behaviors so out of control. We've also been doing behavioral therapy for years, but unfortunatly it didn't help, and took a medication to control his overactive adrenaline rushes. Wait until that DJ has a violently aggressive child or his kiddo is completely debilitated by OCD or anxiety or extreme hyperactivity or hallucinating. Trust me, he will be a believer in medication.
    I do agree too many people medicate first without trying other approaches like changing the environment, school, therapies or special diets. etc. It's getting way out of hand.

  • JenniferWhynott says:

    Once again you are right on in that some parents are lazy and that some doctors are overly eager to medicate. In my opinion I think that parents need to do some research on what they believe their child has and then consult their regular physician. They then need to consult with a person in the medical field best accredited to deal with whatever issues are in question. When a full workup has been done and a diagnosis is agreed upon then the treatment plan should be discussed. Medication can sometimes be helpful as a first step to help get the child focused enough to begin other types of therapies. Sometimes other therapies are best to try first and medication as a later resort. I do advocate for diet changes to a less processed diet rich in a balanced  food group kind of thing.  In our case I wish my kid would eat more than 10 foods.  She is even brand specific.  My six year old is dealing with high anxiety almost to the point of panic attacks, to never medicate her could be detrimental to her well being. We talk every night about what is keeping her frightened and then we pray to God. It seems to be helping but bedtime brings many tears. I feel so bad not being able to help her.  I want to help my children have a good quality of life. I do not to medicate them until they are walking zombies or eradicate who they are. I want them to be able to function highly in society or to the best of their ability if they need medication to do this then they need medication. In many cases their are several medications that treat symptoms so trying different ones may be necessary to find the right mix and/or doseage. Do I think that autism and other disorders can be cured by meds, no!  I also believe that some of the qualities of these disorders should be praised because it is what makes these kids who they are. Who wants to be socially normal anyway.

  • Michael says:

    I'm of the opinion to say NO to medications that attempt to treat symptoms of autism. We looked into them for our now 4 year old and there seemed to be little backing that they truly worked. Some drugs – in some combinations and doses – seemed to work for a small number, but for the majority it was truly a crapshoot.For us – keeping our little one drug free has been the right decision. Who knows? There may be a time when we'll have to reconsider, but for now we're happy with the call.

  • MeganCKitchen says:

    I have a friend who medicates for what I believe are the wrong reasons (so her child does not get "too active and wears her out"), so I completely understand where some people come from on saying its bad.  However, I have also talked over medications with our ped for my son because he has trouble focusing.  We have decided that it isn't time yet to medicate, but the discussion remains open and if it changed his quality of life for the better, i would not hesitate to do it.

  • Silachan says:

    I can't stand people who think that medication is just the easy way out. It's not easy at all. It's not easy to live with the constant debilitating symptoms, therapy isn't easy either. Medicine provides a foundation in many cases so that therapy can come in and help address the issues at hand. I'm currently doing it a bit backwards in my own case- I've started therapy for my own anxiety/depression, and my T has suggested to get evaluated by a psychiatrist and see if there could be any medication available to help "lower" the impact they have on my day to day life.  What good is therapy if you get worried over therapy itself for no reason?? And I completely understand about the symptoms being so intertwined you have to tease them out slowly and carefully. It's difficult for the person, and difficult for the therapists, to work when so many things overlap each other. The ADHD aggravates the anxiety which aggravates the depression and PTSD.
     
    Quality of life is a great way to explain it. Don't let anyone make you feel bad for using medication as one of many tools available to handle things like anxiety and ADHD. It's a tool, one out of many, but to get the job 'done' sometimes you have to use multiple tools with one another.